Delegates at a recent meeting proposed that Africa should ban or discourage exports of raw materials to developed countries. Instead these resources should be developed and added value locally. The AU commission may be requesting Presidents to put their political weight behind such a proposal ahead of the 3rd Africa-Europe Summit in November in Libya.
Indeed such an approach would put local content and value addition policy at the heart of Africa's development plans. Local content is where foreign companies are obliged to procure a percentage of labour, goods and services from the host country. Norway pioneered it. See related post on the Norwegian case study. Brazil, a rising oil giant, is using it.
Two questions to ask are: how many African countries currently have the regulatory, investment and governance environment necessary to efficiently manage and add value to natural resources? Additionally are there legal agreements- regional or bilateral including other barriers that would prohibit such an approach at a national level?
The WTO dimension.
Tariff escalation in developed countries e.g. in fuels, forestry and mining sectors would continue to be a concern. Non tariff barriers e.g. technical regulations, import licensing and prohibitions in value added products would also be prohibitive.
WTO rules (e.g. GATT Articles I, III, XI, XIII) would ordinarily not permit a WTO Member to undertake a legal measure to ban or discourage exports, even for reasons of poverty. It may be possible to use export taxes especially where natural resources dominate an economy. However there are proposals and/or disputes in the WTO and EPAs seeking to phase them out. There could also be possibilities for developmental flexibility for the economic development of LDCs. GATT Article XI:2 also provides an exception to the ban of export restrictions to prevent critical shortages. In addition, general exceptional measures found in GATT Article XX, could be relevant. These include measures:
XX (g) for the conservation of exhaustible natural resources. However measures taken pursuant to this provision, would need to be implemented in conjunction with restrictions on domestic production or consumption. This is therefore a two part legal requirement- a need to show conservation of exhaustible resources such as fossil fuels and metallic ores and restrictions on domestic production. However even renewable resources can be exhausted if over-traded or mismanaged hence export restrictions may be necessary.
XX (i) involving restrictions of exports of domestic materials necessary to ensure essential quantities of such materials to a domestic processing plant during periods when the domestic price of such materials is held below world price as part of a government stabilisation programme. This is a periodic measure applicable specifically to export restrictions undertaken to ensure sufficient quantities for domestic processing, specifically when domestic price is below world price and as part of an internal price stabilisation scheme. Given the extreme price volatility of certain natural resources, this provision maybe relevant however the precise requirements require dual pricing mechanisms.
XX (j) essential to the acquisition of products in general or local short supply. However such measures must be consistent with the principle that all members are entitled to an equitable share of the international supply of such products.
**********
Participants at a meeting of the African Union’s Trade and Industry Commission yesterday proposed that the continent adopts policies to discourage the export of raw materials to the developed world.
During a media briefing at Munyonyo, Kampala, Ms Elizabeth Tankeu, the Trade and Industry Commissioner, said: “We have been exporting our raw materials to Europe since the colonial times when the Europeans came to Africa. They still come here for our resources but we have remained the poorest continent”.
“The European Union through its Economic Partnership Agreements wants Africa to trade with them at zero per cent tariffs. They say they want reciprocal trade. But we are saying Africa still needs a lot in place for reciprocation to begin. We’re telling them we are not going to continue exporting raw materials.”
More here.
No comments:
Post a Comment