Proposed Levy on Imports to Finance EAC Secretariat

From Business Daily. See more here.

The cost of imported goods looks set to rise as the East Africa Heads of State agreed on a new import levy to finance secretariat operations which have long been hit by unreliable donations and member subscriptions.

The Heads of State on Wednesday called for the conclusion of a more sustainable financing plan for the EAC budget.

The summit directed the council to finalise the work on the modalities required to establish a sustainable financing mechanism for the East African Community based on various options, including a hybrid of a levy and equal contribution with a commitment to increase the budget, that encompasses the principles of equity, solidarity and equality, and submit a report to the next summit for consideration.

EAC Treaty Articles 132:4 and 133 state that the EAC budget shall be funded by equal contributions by the Partner States and receipts from regional and international donations and any other sources as may be determined by the Council. Other resources shall include grants, donations, funds for projects and programmes, technical assistance and income earned from activities undertaken by the Community. 

The region’s council of ministers has previously proposed that member states should consider levying one per cent import duty on goods from non-member states.

The push for a new levy could come with pain for consumers in Kenya and other EAC countries where most of essential goods attract value added tax (VAT) after governments scrapped previous exemptions. 

Consumers in Kenya are already subjected to the recently introduced 1.5 per cent railway development levy (RDL) and the 2.5 per cent import declaration fee charged by the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA). 

The additional one per cent levy would push up the prices for imports — including inputs for making essential commodities. 

Kenya in 2014 unsuccessfully tried to impose the RDL on all imports passing through the port of Mombasa. 

The KRA was forced to review the RDL collections after regional traders filed a complaint with the EAC Council of Ministers citing breaches to the regional common market protocol. 

A regional lobby group, the East African Business Council (EABC), argued that the 1.5 per cent levy imposed on imports was inconsistent with the EAC Customs Union Protocol, because it is a charge of equivalent effect that partner states agreed to remove. 

The customs union protocol enables goods produced within the region to be sold across the borders without duty while imports from non-EAC states are subjected to a three-band common external tariff structure. 

Raw materials attract no duty, intermediate goods are charged at 10 per cent while finished products are allowed into the region at 25 per cent tariff. 

Kenyan traders further said the RDL, which KRA imposed on top of other levies such as the 2.5 per cent import declaration fee, was tilting the competition landscape in the shared market in favour of their neighbours. 

KRA gave in to the pressure in early March 2014 and ordered all its officers to stop imposing levy on goods entering Kenya from the other four member states of the EAC.

EAC Common Revenue Management Model

Traders have blamed payment of taxes at every border point for increased cost of doing business. Border delays and the absence of laws to settle disputes and promote integration have also been cited as hindrances to the opening up of trade in East Africa. 

Well thats about to change.

The East African Community (EAC) 5 Heads of State have endorsed a revenue management model where tax will only be collected at the point of entry and imported goods transported to the final destination without stopping at national border points for customs charges or inspection. 

This approach is similar to that used in the South African Customs Union.

The decision raises hope for a speedy formation of a regional customs authority that would handle the smooth flow of goods across borders — handing traders an opportunity to save up to 15 per cent in extra transit costs that come with delays.

“The Summit adopted in principle the destination model of clearance of goods where assessment and collection of revenue is at the first point of entry and revenues are remitted to the destination partner states subject to the fulfilment of key pre-conditions to be developed by the high level task force,” the heads of state said in a communiqué at the end of a recent regional summit in Arusha.

Though the EAC launched its customs union in January 2010, disagreement over collection and sharing of revenue has frustrated efforts to establish a regional customs authority, slowing down cross-border trade. “We hope the decision brings some change this time by ending the controversy that has been with us for three years now,” Peter Njenga, a logistics officer said.

Kenya has been particularly reluctant to adopt the model that would see the Kenya Revenue Authority (KRA) lose control of close to 35 per cent of its present annual collections. Some member states want the revenue be used to finance projects of common interest such as roads or power generation.

However, Kenya has further hardened its position as it would mean losing a large proportion of tax collection at a time when it faces huge budgetary challenges as it implements the new constitution.

In Nairobi, opposition to a regional customs authority has also come from the port of Mombasa, a key entry point, with Kenya Ports Authority maintaining that extending the facility’s function to include collecting customs revenues will further delay the discharge of cargo given the current levels of congestion.

The setting up of a common revenue authority for the EAC has also been delayed due to the fact that Burundi had not fully emerged from the ravages of a civil war and required time to set up sound national institutions to manage public finances.  For instance in 2008, just one year after it joined EAC, Burundi became the only country in the region to ever report loss of revenue from free movement of goods under the customs union protocol.

This position has since changed with the Burundian President Pierre Nkurunziza recently saying the country is ready for higher stages of integration after hiring the services of Trade Mark East Africa (TMEA) to set up new revenue administration institution—Office Burundais des Recettes.

Article From Business Daily